Transportation for Non-Medical Needs
Select Category
ADVANCED SEARCH
Transportation for Non-Medical Needs
Transportation to obtain non-medical items and services, such as for grocery shopping, banking, and transportation related to any other SSBCI, is a non-primarily health related benefit. Such transportation may be reimbursed, arranged, or directly provided by an MA plan as a SSBCI.
DOWNLOAD CATEGORY
Linking Gap and Impact
2017| American Hospital Association| Google|
Outcome type: Favorable
Reliable transportation is a vehicle for wellness and is essential to accessing health care services. Without reliable transportation, there can be delayed care, increased spending, and overall poorer health.
Other
Linking Gap and Impact
Dupuis J, Weiss DR, Wolfson C
2007| Can J Aging| Google| 17613446| 10.3138/cja.26.2.149
Outcome type: Favorable
A high number of seniors who experience transportation insecurity are women. In addition, those who experience barriers to transportation have poorer health and lower income.
Other
Peer Reviewed
Age > 65
Linking Intervention and Impact
Starbird LE, DiMaina C, Sun CA, Han HR
2019| J Community Health| Google| 30206755| 10.1007/s10900-018-0572-3
This review appraises studies on the types and impact of interventions that address transportation to chronic are management.
Outcome type: Favorable
Transportation insecurity disproportionately affects individuals with chronic diseases. As a result of transportation interventions, studies found an improvement in rates of cancer screening, chronic disease management, hospital utilization, and follow up adherence.
Systematic Review
Peer Reviewed
Linking Gap and Impact
Fraade-Blanar L, Best R, Shih RA
2022| RAND| Google| 10.7249/PEA1615-1
Outcome type: Favorable
Transportation insecurity among older adults can lead to depression, isolation, early entry into care facilities, and delays in care which can be costly and dangerous.
Other
Age > 65
Linking Gap and Impact
Ng AE, Adjaye-Gbewonyo D, Dahlhamer J
2024| CDC| Google|
Outcome type: Favorable
5.7% of US adults lacked reliable transportation in 2022. Particularly among older adults with lower incomes and without insurance, this can lead to reduced access to health care and negative health outcomes overall.
Federal Policy or Report
Linking Gap and Impact
Syed ST, Gerber BS, Sharp LK
2013| J Community Health| Google| 23543372| 10.1007/s10900-013-9681-1
Outcome type: Favorable
A lack of reliable transportation can lead to missed or delayed care and medication use which can harm chronic disease management and lead to poorer health overall.
Other
Peer Reviewed
Linking Intervention and Impact
Fraade-Blanar L, Koo T, Whaley CM
2021| RAND Research Reports| Grey Literature| 10.7249/RRA1019-1
Rideshare-based transportation was provided to individuals with complex conditions primarily for medical services, but the article includes ample data tables that speak to nonmedical needs.
Outcome type: Favorable
Authors found that rideshare-based NEMT could help reduce system strain and satisfy an unmet or poorly met need for on-demand cost-effective solutions within the NEMT ecosystem. Other aspects of the piece address nonmedical transportation needs.
Other
Linking Intervention and Impact
Saxon L, Ebert R, Sobhani M.
2019| The Journal of mHealth| Siren|
This study examines the effect of unlimited transportation access on health among older adults.
Outcome type: Favorable
Improved quality-of-daily-living was reported in 90% of subjects and 66% reported increased social visits.
Prospective Cohort Study
Age > 65
Age ≤ 65
Linking Intervention and Impact
Miller HJ, Tribby CP, Brown BB, Smith KR, Werner CM, Wolf J, Wilson L, Oliveira MG.
2015| Health Place| PubMed| 26340643| 10.1016/j.healthplace.2015.08.005
This study examines the effect of light rail transit on physical activity levels.
Outcome type: Favorable
Building new public transit options is associated with a statistically significant increase in light to moderate physical activity levels
Other
Peer Reviewed
Linking Intervention and Impact
Liddle J, Haynes M, Pachana NA, Mitchell G, McKenna K, Gustafsson L.
2014| Gerontologist| PubMed| 23512770| 10.1093/geront/gnt019
This study evaluates the effect of a group education and support program on community mobility.
Outcome type: Favorable
Participating in the intervention was significantly associated with a higher number of episodes away from home per week. Participation in the intervention also significantly predicted higher use of public transport at immediately postintervention, higher use of walking at immediately postintervention, increased aspects of community mobility self-efficacy, and higher satisfaction with transport at 3-month follow-up.
Randomized Controlled Trial
Peer Reviewed
Linking Gap and Impact
Schryer E, Boerner K, Horowitz A, Reinhardt JP, Mock SE.
2019| J Appl Gerontol| PubMed| 29183239| 10.1177/0733464817741683
Outcome type: Neutral
Driving cessation of older adults was associated with a decline in life satisfaction among social partners but not for the drivers. Life satisfaction was greater among the social partners of ex-drivers who used public transportation more frequently.
Prospective Cohort Study
Peer Reviewed
Age > 65
Linking Intervention and Impact
Evans JT, Stanesby O, Blizzard L, Jose K, Sharman MJ, Ball K, Greaves S, Palmer AJ, Cooper K, Gall SL, Cleland VJ.
2023| Int J Behav Nutr Phys Act| PubMed| 37587424| 10.1186/s12966-023-01500-7
This study aimed to determine the effect of a financial incentive-based intervention on public transportation use and physical activity.
Outcome type: Favorable
This study found evidence that financial incentive-based intervention to increase public transport use is effective in increasing transport-related physical activity
Randomized Controlled Trial
Peer Reviewed
Linking Gap and Impact
Arnason T, Tanuseputro P, Tuna M, Manuel D.
2019| Can J Public Health| PubMed| 30628043| 10.17269/s41997-018-0168-9
Outcome type: Favorable
A population-level municipal transportation policy shift could prevent as many as 1620 incident cases of diabetes over 10 years, the largest number prevented by increases in public transit use. This population effect was equal to 17,300 inactive individuals or 12,300 inactive individuals > 45 years old undertaking a clinical preventive intervention to increase physical activity.
Prospective Cohort Study
Peer Reviewed
Linking Gap and Impact
Borisoff JF, Ripat J, Chan F.
2018| Arch Phys Med Rehabil| PubMed| 29580935| 10.1016/j.apmr.2018.02.011
Outcome type: Favorable
Among people who use wheelchairs to participate and move at home and in the community, mobility was affected by seasons and daily weather. Inaccessible public environments were the primary barrier to community mobility and participation; access to social supports and private transportation were the primary supports.
Prospective Cohort Study
Peer Reviewed
Linking Gap and Impact
Jellema S, van Hees S, Zajec J, van der Sande R, Nijhuis-van der Sanden MW, Steultjens EM.
2017| Clin Rehabil| PubMed| 27681480| 10.1177/0269215516671013
Outcome type: Favorable
The following environmental factors facilitated reengagement in personally valued activities post-stroke: personal adapted equipment; accessible environments; transport; services; education and information.
Systematic Review
Peer Reviewed
Age > 65
Stroke
Linking Gap and Impact
Bernstein DN, Lans A, Karhade AV, Heng M, Poolman RW, Schwab JH, Tobert DG.
2023| Clin Orthop Relat Res| PubMed| 36201422| 10.1097/CORR.0000000000002446
Outcome type: Favorable
A lack of reliable transportation was associated with worse physical and mental health symptoms at new patient encounters among patients with orthopedic conditions.
Other
Peer Reviewed
Linking Intervention and Impact
Ogilvie D, Panter J, Guell C, Jones A, Mackett R, Griffin S.
2016| Health impacts of the Cambridgeshire Guided Busway: a natural experimental study| PubMed| 26764445| 10.3310/phr04010
This review analyzes the effect of investment in new high-quality transport infrastructure on increase in active commuting and wider health impacts of changes in travel behavioral, and determinants of the use and uptake of active commuting.
Outcome type: Favorable
New transit affected commuting behavior. Observational evidence suggesting a relationship between active commuting, greater overall physical activity, and improved well-being and weight status.
Other
Peer Reviewed
Linking Intervention and Impact
Latham-Mintus K, Manierre M, Miller K.
2022| Gerontologist| PubMed| 34133722| 10.1093/geront/gnab084
This study examines the effect of alternative transportation use on participation in diverse social activities among older adults
Outcome type: Favorable
The use of public transportation, paratransit, getting a ride, or walking/using wheelchair/scooter to get places was associated with participating in more types of social activities. Respondents who used alternative transportation had less steep declines in participation. The effect of getting rides and using paratransit services was more pronounced among respondents living in disordered neighborhoods.
Other
Peer Reviewed
Age > 65
Linking Intervention and Impact
Zhu J, Yang Y, Zeng Y, Han X, Chen W, Hu Y, Qu Y, Yang H, Valdimarsdóttir UA, Fang F, Song H.
2023| J Gerontol A Biol Sci Med Sci| PubMed| 36815559| 10.1093/gerona/glad064
This study examines the relationship between physical activity behaviors and patterns with acceleration of the aging process. Physical activity patterns include activities such as walking, light and heavy housework, and use of public transportation.
Outcome type: Favorable
Public transportation use was associated with a lower risk of aging acceleration
Other
Peer Reviewed
Linking Intervention and Impact
Xiao C, Goryakin Y, Cecchini M.
2019| Am J Prev Med| PubMed| 30777164| 10.1016/j.amepre.2018.10.022
Meta-analysis evaluating the association between new public transportation options and intensities of physical activity.
Outcome type: Favorable
Building new public transit options is associated with a statistically significant increase in light to moderate physical activity levels
Meta Analysis
Peer Reviewed
Linking Intervention and Impact
Chaiyachati KH, Hubbard RA, Yeager A, Mugo B, Shea JA, Rosin R, Grande D.
2018| J Gen Intern Med| PubMed| 29380214| 10.1007/s11606-018-4306-0
This study evaluates the effect of rideshare-based medical transportation on the proportion of Medicaid patients attending scheduled primary care appointments.
Outcome type: Favorable
NEMT increased show rate; odds of showing at intervention site were 2.57 times more than control site. The authors also included an extensive description of transportation barriers faced by low-income patients that extends to non-medical transportation needs.
Prospective Cohort Study
Peer Reviewed
Linking Intervention and Impact
Shekelle PG, Begashaw MM, Miake-Lye IM, Booth M, Myers B, Renda A.
2022| BMC Public Health| PubMed| 35449011| 10.1186/s12889-022-13149-1
The study examines the association between interventions aimed at reducing barriers to non-emergency transportation and non-medical transportation and health and health care utilization.
Outcome type: Neutral
NEMT interventions lead to fewer missed appointments. NMT lead to improved QOL, but no change in satisfaction with life or depression.
Meta Analysis
Peer Reviewed
Linking Intervention and Impact
Thomas LV, Wedel KR, Christopher JE
2018| J Rural Health| Siren| 28370462| 10.1111/jrh.12239
This study examines the association between Medicaid-provided non-emergency medical transportation and diabetes care visits.
Outcome type: Favorable
Use of nonemergency medical transportation is a significant predictor of diabetes care visits. Positive association between the use of transportation and number of visits.
Other
Peer Reviewed
Diabetes
Linking Intervention and Impact
Solomon EM, Wing H, Steiner JF, Gottlieb LM
2020| Med Care| Siren| 31985588| 10.1097/MLR.0000000000001292
This study summarizes existing research on the effectiveness of non-emergency medical transportation interventions.
Outcome type: Neutral
Results were mixed. More rigorous studies showed low patient uptake of transportation services and inconsistent impacts on health and utilization outcomes.
Systematic Review
Peer Reviewed
Linking Gap and Impact
Holcomb J, Highfield L, Ferguson GM, Morgan RO
2022| J Gen Intern Med| Siren| PMC9585111| 10.1007/s11606-022-07403-w
Outcome type: Favorable
Using data from the Greater Houston Accountable Health Communities (GH-AHC) model, transportation was identified as a health-related social need for 28% of participants.
Other
Peer Reviewed
Age > 65
Age ≤ 65
Linking Gap and Impact
Graboyes EM, Chaiyachati KH, Sisto Gall J, Johnson W, Krishnan JA, McManus SS, Thompson L, Shulman LN, Yabroff KR
2022| J Natl Cancer Inst.| Siren| 36130286| 10.1093/jnci/djac134
Outcome type: Favorable
As a result of transportation insecurity, patients with cancer may forego, miss, delay, alter, and/or prematurely terminate necessary care. Limited data suggest that these alterations in care have the potential to increase the rates of cancer recurrence and mortality and exacerbate disparities in cancer incidence, severity, and outcomes.
Other
Peer Reviewed
Cancer
Linking Gap and Impact
Shafer PR, Davis A, Clark JA
2023| BMC Health Serv Res| Siren| 38087286| 10.1186/s12913-023-10446-2
Outcome type: Neutral
Transportation as a barrier to care among Medicare enrollees with multiple chronic illnesses came up relatively less frequently in chronic care management encounters (0.1%).
Other
Peer Reviewed
Age > 65